| | |  | Big Dance Bands | Home » » » Rameau - Les Indes Galantes / Petibon, Croft, Hartelius, Agnew, Rivenq, Berg, Strehl, Christie, Les Arts Florissants, Paris Opera | | | | | | | Product Details: | | | Actors:
| Richard Croft, Patricia Petibon, Danielle de Niese, Paul Agnew, William Christie | | Director:
| Thomas Grimm DVD-Director | | Format:
| Classical, Color, DVD, Widescreen, NTSC | | Language:
| French | | Subtitle:
| German, English, Spanish, Italian, French | | Number of Discs:
| 2 | | Studio:
| BBC / Opus Arte | | Run Time:
| 190 minutes | | DVD Release Date:
| August 16, 2005 | | Average Customer Rating:
|  based on 15 reviews |
| | | | Used and New: | | | |
| All | |
| $23.98 | New | | | $23.99 | New | | | $27.99 | Used
- VeryGood | | | $27.99 | Used
- VeryGood | | | $28.71 | New | | | $31.12 | New | | | $32.93 | New | | | $32.93 | Used
- Mint | | | $32.94 | New | | | $34.84 | New | | | $35.99 This item ships for FREE with Super Saver Shipping. | New | | | $36.05 | New | | | $37.46 | New | | | $37.58 | New | | | $38.27 | New | | | $41.88 | New | | | $75.94 | New | |
| New | |
| $23.98 | New | | | $23.99 | New | | | $28.71 | New | | | $31.12 | New | | | $32.93 | New | | | $32.94 | New | | | $34.84 | New | | | $35.99 This item ships for FREE with Super Saver Shipping. | New | | | $36.05 | New | | | $37.46 | New | | | $37.58 | New | | | $38.27 | New | | | $41.88 | New | | | $75.94 | New | |
| Used | |
| $27.99 | Used
- VeryGood | | | $27.99 | Used
- VeryGood | | | $32.93 | Used
- Mint | |
| | | | Customer Reviews: | |
Average Customer Review:
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
 Excellent Baroque Opera Production and DVD!Nov 28, 2009
I saw a clip from this production on YouTube and knew I just had to get the DVD, which I found here on Amazon at a very good price.
The DVD is excellent, clear and sharp and the menus (in French) get you around the disc pretty easily. All of the content is in French, but the subtitles cover it nicely for those who don't understand the language.
Pros:
Fantastic performances and production
The Extras sections are very helpful in understanding the opera
Cons:
None to speak of, except two-line subtitles are hard to read when the white type appears over an orange or yellow background.
Review:
Baroque Opera is something of an acquired taste to be sure. Often, these operas are performed in an historical perspective, with singers used as they were originally intended (counter-tenors or female singers for "castrati", etc.) While this may be accurate to the history, it is difficult for our modern tastes.
"Les Indes" as presented here takes a more modern approach. The orchestration is rich and full, the singers are strong, and there is a lot of wonderful choreography. Although the pacing is a tad slow, the music of course, sustains it, and the set designs, costuming, make-up, choreography, and performers make up for the pacing.
Anyone new to this DVD of the production (or the opera itself) would get a lot out of the Extras section, especially the bonus film called "Swinging Rameau". This explains the synopsis of the opera (which is made up of four separate love stories), the approach taken in the production, and answers all questions about why they did what they did. You see, they are focusing on the imagination here, the imagination of the composer in telling the stories in music, and the imagination of the company in bringing the composer's vision to life.
While this approach may not be to everyone's tastes, I certainly found it inventive and intriguing.
A lot of historical Baroque Opera involves people standing around on stage, either singing or waiting to sing. This can get very tedious. In this production, the choreographer keeps things moving -- both the principles and extras in the cast -- so we don't get bored. There is a lot to see at every turn. It is thought provoking.
This performance also has a lot of whimsy to it. It's good humored fun, reflective of the opera (it's not a comic opera, but it is certainly "light" compared to the more common "tragic" operas of the time) and while it is always professional, it takes a light hearted approach that is engaging and makes the opera much more accessible.
I have read some reviews that claim this performance is more like a circus than an opera. Certainly, I can see the reference, as many of the dancers are acrobatic, the make up and costuming is bold and engaging, and the props are big and bold.
In a scene about a shipwreck, they use props for the waves to great effect, in another scene there are mountains that move and shake, and there is a giant golden chicken or turkey brought in at the end -- why I have not figured out, nor why they turn it so the audience is looking at its backside... may be an "in" joke! Yet, the sets are minimal and bright, giving the whole thing a "circus" and entertaining atmosphere to be sure. But this opera is no joke or parody. It is serious and genuine to itself with a charm that is hard to describe. I think this approach makes it fun, and when was the last time a Baroque Opera was fun to watch?
The cast is superb -- no other way to describe them. The singers -- principles as well as chorus -- are clear, on pitch and on time, and they move about and use facial expressions to engage the audience. The dancers are excellent, well timed, at times absolutely thrilling to watch. The choreography is a mix of traditional baroque ballet with modern interpretative dance, and it works! This again is a modern approach to historical "set singing", and I think a good one. The camera work is also quite good, with plenty of close-ups as well ensemble shots.
Perhaps the best part of the opera is the end, with a fully orchestrated and choreographed performance of "Les Sauvages" (also the name of that story in the opera). This started life as a harpsichord piece which Ramaeau re-worked into the opera. As a harpsichord piece, it was -- and is -- one of the "top 10", and as an orchestral and choral piece, Rameau gave it even more life and excitement, as does this performance. It is the highlight of a show filled with highlights -- so much so that when they roll the credits, the conductor and cast reprise the music in a dance of joy. Very moving stuff.
In short this DVD and performance celebrates Rameau and his music.
I would recommend this opera DVD to anyone who loves good music. It has great re-play value, and you do have to watch it more than once to get all the inside jokes, the subtleties, the nuances. That makes it a good value for the money.
A+++ for this wonderful production and technically excellent DVD!
1 of 1 found the following review helpful:
Enchanting Intensity !Jul 28, 2009
The magnificent Les Arts Florissants conducted by William Christie perform this fabulous French Baroque opera with enchanting intensity. As in Rameau's Les Boreades, Paul Agnew is excellent here as well. Danielle de Niese, Patricia Petibon and Nicolas Rivenq are stunning. The marvelous combination of ultra-modern dance and Baroque music doesn't distract from the original premise of the opera, and imbues this gripping drama with vigor and spectacular excitement. As a total artistic experience and grand entertainment, this production is outstanding. Utterly exciting and highly entertaining, this is truly the best Rameau DVD out there !
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Opera as a total artistic expression,.....delightfullSep 12, 2007
In which moment of life "the opera" concept took away the DANCE?
Seven years ago, in Cancun, a french friend recomended me to enjoy this opera, he was in a live performance in Paris. Now I can say it is one of my favorites operas. The production is espectacular, the music just wonderfull.
4 of 4 found the following review helpful:
OUT OF 120 DVD, THIS IS THE MOST BEAUTIFULJul 23, 2007
I have been checking out library opera DVDs for over a year with the hope that I can find another production of equal quality to this one. So far only a few have come close. Most have serious staging problems often called Eurotrash.
If I was not a fan of one of the singers (Malin Hartelius) I might have missed out on this wonderful production as Rameau is not a composer that I collect.
To all those people who wished that the dance was Baroque, let me say that most people would be bored by baroque dance, after a few minutes. This is a brilliant blending of modern dance and baroque music.
2 of 4 found the following review helpful:
 Musically rushedJul 10, 2007
Great to see this staged, but the music is so terribly driven - fast, even rushed - to the extreme. So much of the beautiful detail is lost. Much prefer to listen to Bruggen.
| | |
|
