Average Customer Review:
( 10 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 10 found the following review helpful:
Romance is deadNov 13, 2003
By Casey Snider Don't pick up this DVD expecting to see a classical rendition of this famous tale...you will be sorely disappointed. The Lyon Opera Ballet's "Romeo and Juliet" is a hard-edged, sterile, and chilly retelling of one of the most famous love stories in history. Angelin Preljocal's choreography is described on the box as "startling", and that much certainly applies --- the choreography is decidedly modern, with not a pointe shoe in sight. The problem is, it doesn't seem to fit the music. Let's look at the "Balcony Scene" as an example. If you've ever seen a production of the original Kenneth MacMillan choreography, you'll remember the soaring lifts and sense of giddy abandonment that accompanies Prokofiev's exquisite score. Don't look for that here. The scene starts as Romeo slits an armed guard's throat on a catwalk. Juliet sheds her oversized white shirt to reveal what looks like bike shorts and an elongated corset with bizarrely accented nipples (?!) as Romeo enters. The music takes flight but our lovers remain obstinately earthbound, groveling, stomping, and flailing in a pas de deux that more often resembles a violent rape than the tender meeting of smitten young lovers. In one repeated motif, Romeo tries to fling Juliet's limp arms around his neck several times, only to have them drop bonelessly down again. The Kirov this is not. In the interest of full disclosure, I have to say that I've never liked modern dance to begin with, and this production did nothing to change my mind. The dancers aren't BAD, mind you; watch for some stunning feats of agility and strength. In her first entrance, Pascale Doye (Juliet) performs a forward bend into arabesque and rises slowly onto half-toe, then does several passes before moving into an agonizingly slow developpe a la seconde, again rising to half-toe with nary a wobble. (Also, watch for the German shepherd later in the ballet.) It's just that this production is murky and cold, and it's hard to tell what's going on at times. Still, if you enjoy avant-garde choreography you might want to give this one a look. But if you don't, steer clear.
2 of 3 found the following review helpful:
An Absolute WasteJul 25, 2005
By Gordon S. Cook Jr.
"telecom journalist"
I have seen this danced by the Royal Ballet in the 1960s and by the Kirov in 1996. This is a travesty. Snippets of the music... not the full score with scene fillers by some other modernist. This to me was a porn version - shortened at 85 minutes - the full score runs more than 140 and even the traditional La Scala version is 115.
I was a fool not to read the reviews fully here before I purchased. I since have bought the LaScala version which is fine. The first customer review about says it all - don 't pay any attention to the official Amazon one.
Everyu thing here is trashed...music dancing and story.
Very Fine ProductionApr 15, 2012
By tk I received this DVD as part of a 4 DVD set with Swan Lake, Sleeping Beauty and Nutcracker. This set is still available as of 15 April, 2012. What a nice surprise this Romeo and Juliet was for me. Avant-garde choreography, a dark, industrial type set, bold costumes and fine dancers add up to a wonderful performance. This is an edgy performance. Not traditional. This Juliet is no shrinking violet. She has an attitude. My favorite character is Tybolt. His is a comanding performance. Sort of the Darth Vader of ballet with his black costume with a bit of red. He is the last person we see at the end of the performance.
The technical aspects of this DVD are very good. Very clean picture and clear audio combine with camera work that doesn't call attention to itself make for a very enjoyable experience.
There is a small amount of music added to the Prokofiev score. I have no problem with this. I do regret the serious cuts in the glorious music of Prokofiev so I have to deduct a star.
The choreography is by Angelin Preljocaj. Ballet Preljocaj passed thru recently on their North American tour. I saw Blanche Neige (Snow White). I bought the DVD also. I strongly recommend Blanche Neige. Why doesn't Amazon US have it?
travestyAug 17, 2011
By Anthony Di Russo
"anthony"
This was the worst version of Romeo and Juliet imaginable.
Ugly sets, ugly costumes, ugly choreography.
I watched it all the way thru hoping it would improve. Never did. I was glad when it ended.
Magnicent, creative, artistic, sensual masterpiece!!!!Jul 11, 2010
By Thomas E. Ascher Be careful not to be put off by those who don't like modern ballet! If you want great traditional performances, go for the Paris Opera version, or even the early Russian Ulanova version. Both artistic triumphs. But don't discount this Opera de Lyon version which is equal in its own right. It grabbed me emotionally and intellectually. The choreographer, Angelin Preljocaj thought this through and made choices that provide a meaningful, insightful, interpretation. I loved watching this.
See all 10 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|